My son went out for Halloween as Harry Potter before there were movies or store-bought costumes, so…

Harry Potter flies his Numbus 2000 low through a graveyard on October 31st, 2000.

In the Year 2000 there were only 5 Harry Potter Books and no Harry Potter movies.  We worked out the costume from information in the books.   ALT

My son went out for Halloween as Harry Potter before there were movies or store-bought costumes, so we worked out what his costume ought to be from the books. Can you imagine: he had to explain who he was supposed to be at a lot of the doors he trick-or-treated. He loved the fact Harry Potter wore glasses like he did.

I’ve been organizing my photos and it bothers me how important Harry Potter was in my son’s childhood.

The first I heard of the book series was that some parents wanted the books banned from the school library. Nothing could have inspired me to run out and buy the first one any faster than that. It was clear that one way or another, Harry Potter was going to be an important part of the culture of my son’s generation, so had the book turned out to be satanic junk, when I read it to him, we could have talked about it. And if it was half as good as advertised, we wouldn’t have wanted to miss any of it.

The Gryffindor Crest I made for my kid's doorALT

It was good, and the themes were powerful. It was interesting that the books matured with their readers. And my son grew up, learning some good lessons therein, and by the time the final book came out, I had to pre-order two copies because I didn’t want to wait the day it would take him to devour the thing before I could read it.

And of course, my son grew up and moved on. But as great as the Harry Potter experience was, the whole thing has been soiled by Ms Rowling’’ virulent anti-trans advocacy. I might say it was on par with Frank L. Baum’s racism, but at the time Baum made his splash, he wasn’t out of step with his times.

So much in the Harry Potter books seemed to support inclusion, this seemed to be out in left field.

TWEET
@jk_rowling
If sex isn’t real, there’s no same-sex attraction. If sex isn’t real, the lived reality of women globally is erased. I know and love trans people, but erasing the concept of sex removes the ability of many to meaningfully discuss their lives. It isn’t hate to speak the truth.

@ScarletEnvyNYC
You’ve written so many, but these are the words you will be remembered for.
7:20 PM · Jun 6, 2020  from Brooklyn, NY
ALT

We ought to know better. Jo Rowling ought to know better. The excuse for this “activism” is supposedly meant as “protection” for women. (Funny, that was/is often the excuse for racism.)

Attacking anyone for being different is never self protection. It certainly doesn’t protect *any* women. Such anti-trans nonsense has actually caused a lot of problems for a cis women who have been hassled and attacked because misogynists decided they weren’t real women either. People who buy into this mindset are justifying judging all women based on what they look like.

Women who you don’t look womanly enough might be banned from using the appropriate toilet. Worse, people, women, real women, not the mythological boogymen pretending to be women so they can more easily attack women that Ms Rowling is afraid of. Real women come in many shapes and sizes. Biology has long outstripped the binary worldview Ms Rowling cherishes.

My son as Harry Potter at the local Chapters Book Store book launch party.  I started making his costume before any of the movies came out, and he's holding the wand I made from a piece of bamboo painted gold with a green glowstick inserted at the end, wearing the Gryffindor cloak complete with the Gryffindor crest I painted from the book.  The bookstore furnished the stuffed Hedwig sitting on his shoulder.ALT

One of the reasons I became a writer was to help make sense of the world. To help me understand other people’s points of view. But what I’ve never understood what kind of privileged arrogance makes anyone believe themselves entitled to tell other people who or what they should be.

In her persistent crusade to erase the identities of trans people, what Ms Rowling is doing with the outsized platform and insane amount of privilege she wields as Harry Potter’s creator, she is effectively doing the same thing her Lord Voldemort did in attacking “mud bloods.”

So while we still have the books in my house, and the first few movies, but they’ve not been re-read or watched again. There are so many good books and movies that haven’t been tainted by hate speech. Why bother? We certainly haven’t (and won’t) been passing them along to any children.

It is lovely that so many of the actors and others involved with the Harry Potter phenomenon have stood up against Ms Rowling’s unfeeling crusade.

https://variety.com/2020/film/news/emma-watson-daniel-radcliffe-sarah-paulson-condemn-jk-rowling-anti-trans-tweets-1234630870/

If I were to write a character who was a Rowling-like children’s author who engaged in anti-trans activism, I could imagine a number of reasons, all bad or sad, as to why such a wildly successful author character might persist in their hate based crusade against a group of innocent people. But that would be fiction.

In reality, I don’t know why, and truth be told, I don’t actually care. People often lie to themselves to justify their fear based hate. I am probably more offended by Mr Rowling when they claim to “love trans people” with one side of their mouth, then proceed to try to erase them with the other.

What Ms Rowling is doing here is hurting trans people. Ans well as their friends, families and communities.

TWEET
J.K. Rowling @jk_rowling ☑️
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I know and love Trans people but . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ALT

There is no possible justification.

Costume Parade [Part Two]

left photo: the finished cat, right photo I'm face painting the cat

1998: Year of the Cat

Growing up with cat siblings, it was only natural that my son would want to be a cat one year. The cat costume made of thick fake fur was a particularly good choice for 1999’s bitterly cold Hallowe’en.

I left the face open and attached black raffia whiskers to the sides of the face. Large black craft foam claws were sewn to the costume’s front paws.

Two photos, one a head and shoulders shot and the other a full body shot of the pirate costume.ostume

1999: Dread Pirate

My son decided he wanted to be a pirate in the first grade.  For the hat, I transformed my wide-brimmed dressy felt hat into a traditional pirate hat, trimming the edges with gold ribbon to make the outline stand out. I used a sheet of white craft foam to cut out a skull and cross-bones.  The piratical striped shirt and bandana was part of his ordinary wardrobe already.

The cape is trimmed with the same gold ribbon, and held together with a chain clasp.  I also made a shoulder “swag bag” to hold all the accoutrements,  The two main weapons were a plastic cutlass, and a reproduction antique pistol (a non-functioning lighter).

We had a lot of fun making all the pirate accoutrements for this one. The spyglass was made from two different sized thick cardboard towel rolls that could nest together with a clear Pringles lid attached as the “lens”  Then I made a piratical treasure map, which was painted it with lemon juice and baked in the oven so it would acquire the patina of antiquity.  There was also a pirate flag made with leftover black fabric hung on a bit of bamboo.  I made white foam skulls in appropriate sides to adorn the back of the cape, the flag, and the spyglass.

Harry flies his Nimbus 2000 through the graveyard on Hallowe'en

2000: Harry Potter

My son wanted to be Harry Potter before the first movie was made.  So research for this costume required my return to the source material of the books.

We needed a wand.  Since a visit to  Ollivanders Wand Shop was out of the question, a nice hollow piece of Bamboo — painted gold — was just the ticket.  Next insert a nice Phoenix feather (either a found bird feather, or one purchased from a craft supplier) and tamped down with an appropriately sized glowstick. The glowsticks I used were intended as earings, so there were two to a package, found at the Dollar Store. One of these glowsticks will last out the night, but it is always handy to have backups, particularly as such inexpensive glowsticks have a higher incidence of not activating).

The key element of clothing for Hogwarts students was a nice back wizarding robe to be worn over ordinary street clothes.  To make the costume more Harry Potter specific, I decided to make a Hogwarts crest for young Harry’s book bag.   There was a beautiful black and white line art rendering of the Hogwarts crest in the books. Since this drawing was uncredited, I assumed it to be the work of author J.K.Rowling (which seems now to be the consensus on the Internet). The books told me which colours were required for each of the Hogwarts houses.

I transformed a small straw broom into a Nimbus 2000 by removing the stitching to make it flat, then binding the straw in a circle. I stained the handle and painted “Nimbus 2000” on the shaft, then varnished it.

He loved the costume, but his biggest disappointment when Trick or Treating was that most people had no idea who Harry Potter was.

This costume was reused again later, when he attended a Harry Potter book launch with the addition of a Griffindor crest to the wizarding robe, which was somewhat shorter now, as he’d grown in the intervening years.

Left: sitting outside Wordsworth, reading the new book; right top, with Hagrid, bottom, full costume

left: aiming the long bow toward the sky, right: wielding the sword

2001: Robin Hood

For my own amusement, my son’s Robin Hood costume *had* to be based on the Errol Flynn costume from the Warner Brother’s classic. My research for this one involved searching through the film and making sketches of all the necessary bits.

I chose to diverge from the movie, following convention (and the movie poster) in making my son’s hat green, rather than brown. We used a fairly spectacular found feather for the cap. The crenelated tunic was a little bit finicky but not so difficult to sew. I am not the world’s best seamstress, and I try to make costumes durable, I use fabric that doesn’t fray and unravel easily, and it is always a bonus if the stitching can disappear into it.

I put gromets into the v neck of the collar to thread leather lace through, but the gromets never gripped the soft yielding fabric, and started pulling out from the start. After I had to remove them, the laces stayed in the holes just fine on their own.

Both Historically and cinematically, Robin Hood’s weapon of choice was the long bow, so that was an important bit. Since a long bow is almost as tall as it’s user, I pruned an appropriately long and skinny branch from the hedge, and used green twine for the bow-string. I wound a scrap of black leather around the centre of the bow to make a grip. I also sewed him a leather scrap wrist guard, such as are still used by traditional archers today, to protect the shooting arm from bow-string chafing.

I made a quiver out of green fabric, and by slitting the wide ends of some skinny bamboo garden stakes, I was able to push in large green craft feathers to fletch the arrows. The pointier tip ends were pushed into corks for safety. (Before letting him loose on the world I asked him to shoot arrows a leaf bag target, and after seeing how gently they flew, I asked him to shoot some at me for photographs. Even the ones that hit didn’t really hurt.

(Still, when he wore the costume to school for the fourth grade Hallowe’en party, he knew he would lose the weapon if he so much as pulled an arrow out of the quiver.) Sometimes a cork would break on impact, but then the arrow had to be retired until it could be re-tipped.)

He wore this (without the fleece under layer) later to attend the Robin In The Hood Festival.

King Richard kneels to the left of young Robin Hood, gripping the sword

2002: Captain Jean Luc Picard, U.S.S. Enterprise,
Star Trek Next Generation

By this point I had pretty much established that my son could be anyone he wanted to be for Hallowe’en so long as I there was enough advance notice given. For this one, his dad sent away for a Star Trek Next Generation badge/communicator which provided a lovely touch of authenticity to what was essentially a simple costume..

For the tunic and pants I again used my favourite costume fabric, arctic fleece, which has a bit of stretch capability but is quite forgiving for those of us who really only take on one of these projects once a year. Unlike most of the other costumes I’ve made, this one had to be pretty form-fitting, so it wasn’t revisited in later years.

It seems my son is as much a purist as I, as he insisted on having his head shaved for this one. The hairdresser was uncomfortable going all the way, so after a buzz cut the final close shave was undertaken by Dad. Even then, my son’s dark roots were clearly visible under the translucent skin of his perfectly smooth scalp, so a layer of flesh tone make up was required.

Standing in front of a poster of the starship Enterprise

forward arrow

Forward to Part Three