My Submission to The Canadian Environment Minister’s Public Consultation

My Submission to The Canadian Environment Minister’s Public Consultation

Q1. What opportunities do you think the Government of Canada should pursue to reduce emissions by 40-45% below 2005 levels by 2030 and position Canada to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, including in any or all of the following economic sectors? Please elaborate on your answers where appropriate, including any specific insights on policy opportunities or initiatives.

Q1 – Buildings

Since…


View On WordPress

My Submission to The Canadian Environment Minister’s Public Consultation

Q1. What opportunities do you think the Government of Canada should pursue to reduce emissions by 40-45% below 2005 levels by 2030 and position Canada to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, including in any or all of the following economic sectors? Please elaborate on your answers where appropriate, including any specific insights on policy opportunities or initiatives.

Q1 – Buildings

Since buildings are the source of 12% of our GHG emissions, the reasonable first step is to stop building buildings we know need expensive retrofits to get to NetZero.

It’s economical to build to standards we know are necessary.

Since time is of the essence, we need a moratorium on new buildings until we set and adopt a nation-wide net zero emissions building code for 2022, while concurrently developing a model retrofit building code.

Government commitments of $100 million for EV charging stations and grants up to $5000 for home retrofits is a start, but doesn’t go far enough. Especially amid Covid-19 economic challenges, offering homeowners grants to cover a percentage of needed retrofits will help only homeowners with the wherewithal to rennovate. We haven’t the luxury of abandoning homes—and homeowners— who can’t.

Banks could also be obliged to provide low or no-interest loans to retrofit homes.

Q1 – Electricity

Electrify everything and clean up how electricity is produced. Phase out coal but not by switching to natural gas. We need to phase out natural gas too. Nuclear is both too slow to get up and running and too expensive. Do not invest in LNG.

Q1 – Oil and Gas

Eliminate fossil fuel subsidies NOW, as promised in 2015.

Phase-out public financing of the fossil fuel sector, including from Crown corporations.

Q1 – Transportation

We need to electrify transportation With EVs and zero fare public transit. Build intercity transit, implement high performance rail.

Stop subsidizing airlines.

Stop building highways.

Incentivise development of compact, mixed-use communities, and promote work from home and co-share work spaces.

Q1 – Agriculture and Waste

Keep your promise of “Triple funding for cleantech on farms, including for renewable energy, precision agriculture, and energy efficiency.”

We need food security, but we also need to revisit the whole idea of animal agriculture and factory farms.

Stop promising to ban single use plastic and DO IT.

Reduce and eliminate plastic production. Recycling is not enough.

Q1 – Nature Based Climate Solutions

Support conservation of wildlife habitat, nature conservation, wetland restoration, and recreation. Planting seedlings is no replacement for mature trees, especially old growth. Promote bamboo and hemp as alternative quick renewable replacement for paper plastic and wood fibre.

Q1 – Economy-wide (e.g., carbon pricing, climate-risk disclosure, sustainable finance, etc.)

Revenue Neutral Carbon Fee and Dividend is the carbon pricing gold standard but the price has to rise much more rapidly.

Q2. What do you see as the barriers or challenges to reducing emissions in these sectors? Do you have suggestions on how to overcome these barriers?

Lack of political will.

Vote.

Proportional Representation.

Q3. What broader economic, technological, or social challenges and opportunities do you foresee resulting from efforts to reduce emissions in these sectors? For example, opportunities associated with economic diversification across sectors. Do you have suggestions on how to address these challenges and opportunities?

No.

Q4. Looking beyond 2030, what enabling measures, strategies or technological pathways do you think the Government of Canada should put in place now to ensure that Canada is on track to net-zero emissions by 2050?

Stop investing in Fossil Fuels.

Stop investing in military expansion and armaments.

Q5. What broader economic, technological, or social issues to you foresee as a result of the transition to a net-zero economy in Canada? Do you have suggestions on how to address these issues?

Our children will have a livable future


Q6. How would you like to be engaged on Canada’s climate plans moving forward? How often should this engagement occur, and what method or format would be preferable?

Every 6 months.

You need to do a better job engaging the public.

This would be okay but not anonymous.

The questions should be posed better.


I must admit I don’t expect this Liberal government to actually listen. They have been talking about climate action — like stopping fossil fuel subsidies— since 2015. They never actually managed it, yet they did manage to buy a pipeline. Clearly I have good reason to be skeptical. Nonetheless it is important to participate in consultations– even if we think they are simply window dressing— if for no other reason than to get our opinion on the record.

Without Proportional Representation, our Representative Democracy isn’t very accountable to us. But maybe they’ll listen.

Tell the Climate Consultation What You Want!


You don’t have to be a climate expert to partcipate… climate change is already affecting all of our lives. The policies our governments make will either help or make it worse. So far, Canadian policies have only made it worse.

Waterloo Region MPs attending the 2016 Waterloo Region Climate Consultation: (left to right) Liberals Marwan Tabbara (Kitchener South—Hespeler), Bardish Chagger, Waterloo,…


View On WordPress

Climate Consultation: Deadline Midnight

Laurel's Free Culture Blog

The Government of Canada is holding another Climate Consultation. Despite the fact they completely ignored the public input from the 2016 in-person Climate Consultation, it is important for every Canadian concerned about the Climate Crisis to participate. This time, they don’t have a majority government, so they have to at least pretend to listen to us.

You don’t have to be a climate expert to partcipate… climate change is already affecting all of our lives. The policies our governments make will either help or make it worse. So far, Canadian policies have only made it worse.

The deadline for submissions is tonight at midnight, so to make it easier, I’ve reproduced the questions so you can think about what you will say before you go online. It’s important to note that the “tell us more” essay questions each have a 5,000 character limit.

Privacy
They’ve made this an anonymous survey…

View original post 1,569 more words

Climate Consultation: Deadline Midnight

Climate Consultation: Deadline Midnight

The Government of Canada is holding another Climate Consultation. Despite the fact they completely ignored the public input from the 2016 in-person Climate Consultation, it is important for every Canadian concerned about the Climate Crisis to participate. This time, they don’t have a majority government, so they have to at least pretend to listen to us.

You don’t have to be a climate expert to…

View On WordPress

Climate Consultation: Deadline Midnight

The Government of Canada is holding another Climate Consultation. Despite the fact they completely ignored the public input from the 2016 in-person Climate Consultation, it is important for every Canadian concerned about the Climate Crisis to participate. This time, they don’t have a majority government, so they have to at least pretend to listen to us.

You don’t have to be a climate expert to partcipate… climate change is already affecting all of our lives. The policies our governments make will either help or make it worse. So far, Canadian policies have only made it worse.

The deadline for submissions is tonight at midnight, so to make it easier, I’ve reproduced the questions so you can think about what you will say before you go online. It’s important to note that the “tell us more” essay questions each have a 5,000 character limit.

Privacy
They’ve made this an anonymous survey, and we are repeatedly advised not to use any identifying information in our answers. And yet the largest part of the survey is asking for our demographic information, even though they provide a “prefer not to say” answer to each of the demographic questions. Although privacy is an important issue to me, very often we have to make tradeoffs, particularly if we want our voice heard. And the government is more likely to accept our answers as legitimate if we indicate we are Canadians.

(I would also like to point out that if you would be liable to negative repercussions from the government, it would be better to use your own anonymizing method (using a public access machine and going through TOR. If this is impossible, you would do better not to make a submission at all).

THE SURVEY
You’ll find the survey here:
https://eccc.sondage-survey.ca/f/s.aspx?s=4132165a-69ff-455b-9208-24be193aa656&lang=EN&r=94a20c2e-88fb-4585-989c-82da43aff18c

Q1. What opportunities do you think the Government of Canada should pursue to reduce emissions by 40-45% below 2005 levels by 2030 and position Canada to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, including in any or all of the following economic sectors? Please elaborate on your answers where appropriate, including any specific insights on policy opportunities or initiatives.
• Buildings
• Electricity
• Heavy industry, including oil and gas
• Transportation
• Agriculture and waste
• Nature-based climate solutions
• Economy-wide (e.g., carbon pricing, climate-risk disclosure, sustainable finance, etc.)
• Other, please specify
Please tell us more:

Q2. What do you see as the barriers or challenges to reducing emissions in these sectors? Do you have suggestions on how to overcome these barriers?

Q3. What broader economic, technological, or social challenges and opportunities do you foresee resulting from efforts to reduce emissions in these sectors? For example, opportunities associated with economic diversification across sectors. Do you have suggestions on how to address these challenges and opportunities?

Q4. Looking beyond 2030, what enabling measures, strategies or technological pathways do you think the Government of Canada should put in place now to ensure that Canada is on track to net-zero emissions by 2050?

Q5. What broader economic, technological, or social issues to you foresee as a result of the transition to a net-zero economy in Canada? Do you have suggestions on how to address these issues?

Q6. How would you like to be engaged on Canada’s climate plans moving forward? How often should this engagement occur, and what method or format would be preferable?

Demographic questions

D1. In what capacity are you completing this engagement process? As an:
• Individual
• Representative of a business/business association
• Representative of an Indigenous organization
• Representative of a not for profit organization such as a charity or academic organization
• Representative of a government organization
• Prefer not to say
https://eccc.sondage-survey.ca/f/s.aspx?s=4132165a-69ff-455b-9208-24be193aa656&lang=EN&r=94a20c2e-88fb-4585-989c-82da43aff18c

D2. What is your province or territory?
• Alberta
• British Columbia
• Manitoba
• New Brunswick
• Newfoundland and Labrador
• Nova Scotia
• Ontario
• Prince Edward Island
• Quebec
• Saskatchewan
• Northwest Territories
• Nunavut
• Yukon
• Outside of Canada
• Prefer not to say

D3. Please select the option that best relates to your sector (business).
• Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting
• Mining, Quarrying, and Oil and Gas Extraction
• Utilities
• Construction
• Manufacturing
• Wholesale Trade
• Retail Trade
• Transportation and Warehousing
• Information and Cultural Industries
• Finance and Insurance
• Real Estate and Rental and Leasing
• Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
• Management of Companies and Enterprises
• Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services
• Educational Services
• Health Care and Social Assistance
• Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation
• Accommodation and Food Services
• Public Administration
• Other, please specify
• Prefer not to say

D4. Which of the following age groups do you fall into? (individual)
• Under 24
• 25 to 39
• 40 to 64
• 65+
• Prefer not to say

D5. How do you identify yourself? (individual)
• Woman
• Man
• Non-binary
• Other
• Prefer not to say

D6. Do you identify as any of the following? Select all that apply (individual)
• First Nations
• Inuit
• Métis
• Racialized Canadian
• LGBTQ2S+ person
• Person with a disability
• Official language minority
• New immigrant to Canada
• None of them
• Prefer not to say

CONCLUSION

When you’ve reach the end of the survey you can go vack and review or change your answers. When you’re happy about it, press the [SUBMIT] button.

Points You might want to bring up:

Canada must adopt a 2030 emissions reduction target of at least 50%, but 60% would be better.

In 2015 we were promised an end to fossil fuel subsidies. Now we’re told that will finally happen in 2023. That isn’t good enough: it needs to happen now,

Since climate change is an existential threat, the government must spend whatever it will take.

Stop ssearching for new fossil fuel projects.
Stop building new fossil fuel infrastructure, like pipelines and LNG facilities.

If you’re looking for more suggestions, the Green Party’s Mission Possible plan is a great place to start.

  1. Declare a Climate Emergency
    Accept, at every level of government, that climate is not an environmental issue. It is the gravest security threat the world has ever seen.
  2. Establish an inner cabinet of all parties
    Modelled on the war cabinets of Mackenzie King and Winston Churchill, parties will work together to ensure that climate is no longer treated like a political football. It requires all hands on deck.
  3. Set stringent new targets
    Establish our new target and file it as Canada’s Nationally Determined Contribution with the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change: 60 per cent GHG reductions against 2005 levels by 2030; zero emissions by 2050.
  4. Assume leadership
    Attend the next climate negotiation in Chile this year and press other countries to also double their efforts.
  5. Respect evidence
    Restore funding of climate research within the Government of Canada and in the network of universities that received financial support before 2011.
  6. Maintain carbon pricing
    Revenue neutrality will be achieved through carbon fee and dividend and we will eliminate all subsidies to fossil fuels.
  7. Ban fracking
    No exceptions. It destroys ecosystems, contaminates ground and surface water, endangers our health and it’s a major source of GHGs.
  8. Green the grid
    By 2030, remove all fossil fuel generation from our national east-west electricity grid.
  9. And modernize the grid
    By 2030, rebuild and revamp the east-west electricity grid to ensure that renewable energy can be transmitted from one province to another.
  10. Plug in to EVs
    By 2030 ensure all new cars are electric. By 2040, replace all internal combustion engine vehicles with electric vehicles, working with car makers to develop EVs that can replace working vehicles for Canadians in rural areas. Build a cross-country electric vehicle charging system so that drivers can cruise from St. John’s, NL to Prince Rupert, B.C. – with seamless ease.
  11. Get Canada back on track
    Modernize VIA Rail, expand service and ensure trans-modal connections across Canada to light rail and electric buses, so that no one in rural and remote areas of Canada lacks efficient, affordable and safe public transit.
  12. Complete a national building retrofit
    Create millions of new, well-paying jobs in the trades by retrofitting every building in Canada – residential, commercial, and institutional – to be carbon neutral by 2030.
  13. Turn off the tap to oil imports
    End all imports of foreign oil. As fossil fuel use declines, use only Canadian fossil fuels and allow investment in upgraders to turn Canadian solid bitumen into gas, diesel, propane and other products for the Canadian market, providing jobs in Alberta. By 2050, shift all Canadian bitumen from fuel to feedstock for the petrochemical industry.
  14. Switch to bio-diesel
    Promote the development of local, small scale bio-diesel production, primarily relying on used vegetable fat from restaurants. Mandate the switch to bio-diesel for agricultural, fishing and forestry equipment.
  15. Create new partnerships for renewables
    Form partnerships with Indigenous peoples, providing economic opportunities by ramping up renewables on their lands. Harness abandoned deep oil wells, wherever feasible, for geothermal energy, using workers who drilled the wells to manage the renewable energy generation.
  16. Call for all hands on deck
    Engage every municipality and community organization, as well as every school and university to step up and plant trees, install solar panels, heat pumps, assist in retrofitting buildings to maximize energy efficiency.
  17. Prioritize adaptation
    Invest significant resources in adaptation measures to protect Canadian resource sectors such as agriculture, fishing and forestry from the ravages of climate change. Review all infrastructure investments for adaptation to climate change. Map flood plains, tornado corridors and other areas of natural vulnerability and adjust land use plans accordingly.
  18. Change planes
    Cancel the purchase of F35s and buy more water bombers to protect communities from forest fires. Cut standing dead timber to establish fire breaks and save lives.
  19. Curtail the “other” GHG sources
    Address the fossil fuel use that falls outside the Paris Agreement – emissions from international shipping, aviation and the military.
  20. Restore carbon sinks
    Launch a global effort to restore carbon sinks, focusing on replanting forests and restoring the planet’s mangrove forests as quickly as possible.
    https://www.greenparty.ca/en/mission-possible

If you prefer, LEADNOW has put together an identifiable letter form response. https://leadnow.ca/climate-consultation/ I think it better to submit your resonse in the manner the government has asked for, but the most important thing is to submit something.